los angeles labor law lawyer employment lawyer la labor law California

The California Labor Commissioner’s Office hit Amazon hard. It fined the big online store nearly $6 million. The reason was that Amazon didn’t follow the state rules that aim to keep warehouse workers safe. After checking two of Amazon’s sites in Moreno Valley and Redlands, the office found a shocking 59,017 rule-breaking cases1.

This new law started in 2022. It tells companies to share how much work they expect from their workers. This is about things like how many tasks someone should do in an hour. It also talks about what might happen if the worker doesn’t meet these targets. The law’s goal is to stop companies from putting too much stress on their workers. This stress can make workers go too fast, which might lead to more injuries. It can also make workers skip their breaks1.

The places Amazon was fined for are in the Inland Empire region. This area is super busy for Amazon. It has 4.6 million people, 14 Amazon locations, and two air hubs just for moving things. Over 40,000 people work for Amazon there. And, Amazon hired 22,000 new workers in California during COVID-19. Over 8,000 of these new jobs were in the Inland Empire2.

Amazon is fighting back against these fines. It says it doesn’t use set work amounts. Amazon says it looks at how well someone does their job over a long time. But, people are still watching Amazon closely. Other states are also making their own rules to protect warehouse workers, like Minnesota, New York, Oregon, and Washington1.

Key Takeaways

  • California Labor Commissioner’s Office fined Amazon $5.9 million for violating the state’s Warehouse Quotas law
  • Investigations revealed 59,017 violations at two Amazon facilities in Moreno Valley and Redlands
  • The Warehouse Quotas law requires employers to disclose productivity quotas and potential discipline to employees
  • Amazon employs over 40,000 people in the Inland Empire region of California
  • The company has appealed the citations, denying the use of fixed quotas

California Labor Commissioner’s Office Investigates Amazon Warehouses

The California Labor Commissioner’s Office is looking into two Amazon warehouses. They are in Moreno Valley and Redlands, to the east of Los Angeles. This is because workers have complained about unfair work goals. An investigation found that between October 20, 2023, and March 9, 2024, there were 59,017 violations of the state’s Warehouse Quotas Law3.

Moreno Valley and Redlands Facilities Scrutinized

The Commissioner’s Office has fined Amazon $5.9 million. This was for breaking the rules about how much work employees must do. They gave $1.2 million to the Redlands warehouse and $4.7 million to the Moreno Valley one45. Amazon says they don’t have fixed work goals. They say they use a system where workers evaluate each other. But, the Commissioner’s team says this is against the law5.

59,017 Violations of Warehouse Quotas Law Discovered

An investigation found 59,017 times where Amazon broke the law about work quotas. Each violation was worth a $100 fine. So, the total fines were almost $5.9 million3. This law started on January 1, 2022. It makes sure that workers in warehouses are treated fairly. Employers have to explain clearly what they expect from their workers and what might happen if they don’t meet those demands34.

Amazon’s Controversial Productivity Quotas

Amazon has been facing significant scrutiny over its stringent productivity targets, which have become a source of considerable stress for its workforce. Employees are increasingly vocal about the high goals they are required to meet daily, often feeling that these expectations are unrealistic and unattainable. This pressure not only affects their mental health but also raises serious concerns about their physical safety and overall well-being. At the JFK8 warehouse, employees must handle 1,800 packages every hour, which means they have to scan 30 packages per minute6.

Not meeting these quotas could lead to losing their jobs. Packing items at a rate of 700 per hour is demanded from some workers. This shows just how fast-paced the work environment is6. Pickers have only seven seconds to select each item, aiming for 400 units per hour6.

Workers Express Concerns Over Demanding Quotas

The impact on workers’ health is significant, with many facing back and knee pains. They feel their safety concerns aren’t taken seriously6. Being closely monitored by systems, they worry about algorithmic penalties for any shortfall in targets. This creates a very stressful workspace6.

Workers also complain about long security check lines, sometimes up to 20 minutes. They say it feels like a prison, not a workplace6. These delays cut into their breaks and private time, making work-life balance harder to maintain.

Higher Rates of Serious Injuries Compared to Other Warehouse Employers

The pressure to meet Amazon’s targets has caused a rise in serious injuries. At JFK8, the injury rate is three times the warehouse industry’s average. This is based on OSHA data reported by the company6. It’s clear these quotas push employees too hard, affecting their well-being.

Many believe Amazon focuses more on speed than on keeping employees safe. This stance has cost the company 6 million dollars in California alone, tied to its labor practices7. With more and more attention on how it treats staff, Amazon is under pressure to rethink its productivity strategies. It’s urged to put its employees’ health and safety first.

California’s Warehouse Quotas Law Explained

California passed the Warehouse Quotas Law, known as AB 701, on January 1, 2022, to safeguard warehouse workers. This law prevents the use of harmful work quotas. It gives workers clear expectations about their job performance.

Employers Required to Disclose Productivity Quotas and Potential Discipline

If a warehouse has over 100 employees at one site or over 1,000 across several locations, they must share work quota details with each worker. This info should also mention what happens if the quotas aren’t met8.

Workers can ask for their speed data from the last three months to check their performance. If they think a quota is unfair, they can take legal action against their employer. They might get their legal fees paid if they win9.

Law Prohibits Unsafe Quotas Interfering with Breaks and Bathroom Use

Employers can’t set quotas that stop workers from taking breaks or using the restroom legally. This protects employees, making sure they’re not penalized for looking after themselves8.

Many experts praise this law, calling it a milestone. It’s the first to oversee work quotas that use algorithms and ensure they’re clear to workers. This law is a role model for other states to also protect people working in warehouses, where technology is becoming more common.

Amazon’s Response to the Fines

Recently, the California Labor Commissioner’s Office fined Amazon almost $6 million for breaking warehouse quotas laws. Amazon has quickly appealed this fine, and it denies using fixed goals in its worker evaluation system. The fines were over $1.2 million at Redlands and nearly $4.7 million at Moreno Valley10.

Amazon appeals penalties and denies fixed quotas

Amazon’s Maureen Lynch Vogel explained that Amazon doesn’t agree with the claims. She said they use performance expectations. These consider many factors, like team achievements at a site, instead of fixed quotas11.

Company Appeals Penalties, Denies Use of Fixed Quotas

Even with fines totaling $7.8 million since September 2023, Amazon still says they don’t set fixed quotas. It has asked through an appeal to contest the fines and prove its evaluations are fair10.

Amazon Claims to Evaluate Performance Over Extended Periods

Amazon looks at how someone performs over a longer time. It links individual work to the team’s overall success. This approach lets employees check on their performance whenever they want, adding more fairness to the system1011.

Location Penalty Amount
Redlands Warehouse Over $1.2 million
Moreno Valley Warehouse Nearly $4.7 million

Amazon is standing firm against claims of poor work conditions and rule violations. They say they appraise work fairly over time. As the legal process continues, we’ll find out how the courts view Amazon’s system and if it follows California’s laws as it should.

Regulators and Critics Scrutinize Amazon’s Treatment of Employees

Amazon is currently facing significant legal and public scrutiny regarding its treatment of employees. Concerns have been raised about the efficacy of their safety protocols, with data indicating a higher incidence of workplace injuries among Amazon workers compared to those employed at other companies. The number of serious injuries there is twice as high as the industry average12. This has led to questions from members of Congress about the working conditions at Amazon12.

Amazon’s workforce is under fire. In a span of just three weeks, four workers have lost their lives on the job. Such incidents raise serious questions about Amazon’s commitment to its employees, especially when they’re pushed to achieve sky-high productivity targets. There have been tragic events at Amazon, such as the deaths of four workers in just three weeks12.

In Washington state safety regulators have hit Amazon with fines for deliberately putting employees at risk. Even the U.S. Labor Department’s safety division has flagged serious concerns regarding Amazon’s operations. Instead of rectifying these hazardous practices, Amazon is choosing to battle these citations in court. In Washington, state safety regulators fined Amazon for knowingly making workers do tasks that can hurt them13. The U.S. Labor Department’s safety arm has also found issues with Amazon’s practices. Amazon has fought these citations in court.

  • Amazon got fined $6 million in California for not treating its workers fairly14. This big fine shows how serious the situation is13.
  • The laws around work and workers’ rights are changing, which affects how companies do business13.
  • More and more, companies are facing legal actions about how they treat their workers13.

With more cases heading to court, especially over workers’ rights and safety, companies need to be diligent regarding their employer policies and procedures13. Staying within the rules set by state and federal labor laws is key to avoiding problems. The way employment laws are enforced is changing across the country and especially within California. This means companies need to stay ahead with their legal plans13.

Similar Regulations Passed in Other States

Many states are now following California’s example to protect warehouse employees. They are making laws to ensure labor practices are both safe and fair. Among these, New York, Washington, and Minnesota have passed their own regulations. These new laws aim to deal with issues caused by Amazon’s firm stance on productivity quotas15.

States with similar warehouse quotas regulations

New York, Washington, and Minnesota Enact Comparable Laws

In New York, a new bill makes it a must for employers to tell workers about productivity goals. It also bans using these goals to stop employees from taking breaks or using the bathroom. Washington’s law is alike. It requires bosses to clearly explain quotas and the outcomes if employees can’t meet them15.

Minnesota has joined in as well. There, legislation introduced focuses on making sure warehouse workers get reasonable quotas. It also pushes for enough breaks and time for important activities. These states are working to safeguard workers’ well-being while also hitting productivity targets. They aim to avoid the issues seen in Amazon’s California operations15.

Federal Bill Introduced by Senator Ed Markey

Now, the matter of warehouse quotas is on the U.S. federal agenda. Senator Ed Markey from Massachusetts presented a bill last month. This bill would create a national plan for dealing with warehouse quotas. It aims to set rules that are clear, fair, and put worker safety first15.

When the federal bill passes into law, uniform worker protections will be enforced nationwide. This is a critical strike against the exploitative behavior of corporate giants like Amazon. It sends a powerful message: every worker deserves safety and fairness on the job.

California’s smaller businesses must adapt to these new mandates swiftly. Stand strong against potential employment litigation—secure your business with expert legal defense tailored to navigate these evolving laws effectively.

Amazon’s Safety Record Under Fire

Amazon, the e-commerce giant with over 1.5 million employees worldwide16, faces questions about worker safety. Despite spending millions on safety, worries about employee well-being continue.

OSHA Cites Amazon for Exposing Workers to Ergonomic Injuries

OSHA has warned Amazon several times. It’s about workers getting hurt because of how they use their bodies. This can lead to back pain, broken bones, and more – all because they don’t have the right gear or because of accidents.

A high number of Amazon workers have gotten hurt, at 51%, after working there for three years16. OSHA also found issues with how Amazon tracks these injuries. They say Amazon should do more to make its warehouses safer.

Justice Department Investigates Company’s Safety Representations

The Justice Department is looking into Amazon’s safety reports for loans. If found guilty of false claims, this could cause even more concern about how Amazon treats its staff.

Amazon says it’s putting a lot of money, over $300 million, into making work safer in 2021. But, some people feel it’s not enough. The work pressure is high, making employees work 60 hours a week and scan items quickly to keep their job.

Amazon is a major force in online shopping, almost worth $1 trillion. It needs to do more for safety and worker happiness. Not doing this could cause problems with the law and harm how people see the company.

los angeles labor law lawyer employment lawyer la labor law California

Dont struggle with workplace challenges. Dont let them overwhelm you and your business. Our expertise in California’s intricate labor laws makes us the ally you need. We exclusively defend employers and are adept at shielding your business from opportunistic employment lawyers, ensuring you’re always protected and prepared to take on any legal battles head-on.

Employer Lawyer LA employmer attorneys are known for our wins in court. We’ve handled cases involving discrimination, harassment, and more. With decades of experience our attorneys know how to win and how you protect your business.

Knowing California’s latest labor laws is key for employment lawyers. Let us not forget that AB-5 changed many contractors into employees. SB-1162 needs big employers to report pay data to the state starting May 10, 2023. AB-749 stops employers from banning rehires after discrimination lawsuits, which protects workers.

Racism, ageism, sexism, and more at work are illegal in California. Over 19,000 cases a year, so over 1,500 monthly, are about unfair treatment at jobs. Sexual harassment is common, whether it’s a demand for sexual favors in exchange for work or a toxic workplace. You need to know where your company stands. Ignorance of the law will not protect your business.

Conclusion

Amazon was fined $6 million for breaking California’s Warehouse Quotas Law. This shows how important it is for companies to follow labor rules. It also points out the risks if worker safety isn’t a top concern.

This case has shed light on the use of strict productivity goals in warehouses. Employees have complained about being pushed too hard and getting hurt more than in other warehouses. This brings up concerns about the well-being of workers.

In California, companies must share their work goals and warn of punishment for not meeting them. They can’t set goals so high they affect breaks or the restroom. Now, other states like New York, Washington, and Minnesota are making similar laws. Businesses need to be open about their goals and follow these rules to avoid trouble and keep their good name.

Amazon’s practices are being closely checked. They’ve gotten in trouble for work conditions and are under investigation for safety claims. Making sure employees are safe and sticking to the rules is more than just a duty. It’s the right thing to do. People working in California have rights, like extra pay for overtime and a minimum hourly wage of $12. This wage will go up to $15.50 by 2023. Knowing your rights is key to being treated fairly. By learning and speaking up, we can help make workplaces better for everyone.

FAQ

What did the California Labor Commissioner’s Office find in their investigation of Amazon’s warehouses?

The California Labor Commissioner’s Office checked out two Amazon spots. These were in Moreno Valley and Redlands, close to Los Angeles. They found 59,017 issues with how the state’s Warehouse Quotas law was followed.

What does California’s Warehouse Quotas Law require from employers?

This law asks bosses to clarify how much work they expect from workers. They must tell this to workers and the government. Employers can’t set goals that make work unsafe or stop workers from resting or going to the bathroom.

What concerns have been raised about Amazon’s productivity quotas?

Many Amazon workers worry about the goals they’re given. Studies show Amazon’s high injury rates. Workers feel major stress to meet these goals or face being in trouble if they don’t.

How has Amazon responded to the fines imposed by the California Labor Commissioner’s Office?

Amazon said it doesn’t think it did anything wrong and is appealing. They claim not to have exact goals. Instead, they use a mix of measures to know how teams are doing.

What actions have regulators taken against Amazon regarding workplace safety?

In 2022, Washington fined Amazon for making workers do fast work that was risky. The federal OSHA also cited Amazon for safety problems. Amazon is trying to challenge these citations.

Have other states passed laws similar to California’s Warehouse Quotas Law?

Other states, like New York, Washington, and Minnesota, have laws similar to California’s. These laws address quotas set by technology. They make sure bosses are clear with workers about these goals.

What should you do if you are facing issues related to California labor laws?

If you’re having problems with California’s labor laws, get help from LA employment lawyers. They handle issues like the ones Amazon faced with the recent million fine. They can help you understand your rights.

Source Links

  1. https://www.yahoo.com/news/california-fines-amazon-nearly-6m-202751753.html – California fines Amazon nearly $6M, alleging illegal work quotas at 2 warehouses
  2. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/18/magazine/amazon-workers-employees-covid-19.html – Amazon’s Great Labor Awakening (Published 2021)
  3. https://www.workcompacademy.com/2024/06/amazon-cited-6m-for-violating-californias-warehouse-quotas-law/ – Amazon Cited $6M for Violating California’s Warehouse Quotas Law – Work Comp Training, Online Courses, Research, News – WorkCompAcademy – Your Complete Source for Workers Compensation Information
  4. https://www.aol.com/california-fines-amazon-6m-alleged-084800135.html – California fines Amazon $6M for alleged violations of warehouse quota law at 2 warehouses
  5. https://www.fox21news.com/business/ap-business/ap-california-fines-amazon-nearly-6m-alleging-illegal-work-quotas-at-2-warehouses/ – California fines Amazon nearly $6M, alleging illegal work quotas at 2 warehouses
  6. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/feb/05/amazon-workers-protest-unsafe-grueling-conditions-warehouse – ‘I’m not a robot’: Amazon workers condemn unsafe, grueling conditions at warehouse
  7. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40722155 – Amazon fined $5.9M for breaking labor law in California
  8. https://employerlawyerla.com– Were You Fired for Not Making Your Quota at Work?
  9. https://trackbill.com/s3/bills/CA/2021/AB/701/analyses/assembly-labor-and-employment.pdf – Assembly Bill Policy Committee Analysis
  10. https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2024-06-18/amazon-warehouses-in-inland-empire-are-fined-6-million-for-worker-quota-violations – Amazon fined nearly $6 million for violations at Inland Empire warehouses
  11. https://abc7.com/post/amazon-fined-59-million-allegedly-violating-californias-warehouse/14972284/ – Amazon fined $5.9 million for allegedly violating California’s warehouse quota law
  12. https://revealnews.org/podcast/amazon-warehouses-worker-safety-osha/ – A Reckoning at Amazon – Reveal
  13. https://www.huschblackwell.com/industries_services/labor-employment – Labor and Employment Law Firm | Labor Employment Attorneys and Lawyers
  14. https://www.forthepeople.com/practice-areas/labor-and-employment-lawyers/ – Labor and Employment Attorneys
  15. https://shegerianlaw.com/ – Los Angeles Employment Lawyers & Attorneys | Shegerian Law
  16. https://www.rkmlaw.net/worker-compensation/los-angeles-amazon-warehouse-injury-lawyer/ – Los Angeles Amazon Warehouse Injury Attorney – Rose, Klein & Marias LLP.